Op-ed Sunday
Today is my day to take a break from politics and comment on something relatively frivolous.
Hard as it may be to believe, there was a very brief period in MTV’s “Real Word” history where the show was actually on the verge of being interesting. The San Francisco season was when the people at MTV put themselves on the line and made a public statement on the place of AIDS and homosexuality in mainstream culture. Remember Pedro? I don’t know about you but, for people my age, that was the first time I can recall seeing a real gay relationship depicted frankly and sensitively.
But after that it was as if they got scared by the attention they received for being relevant and fell back on finding these bland standard-issue hot people with serious personality and hormonal issues simply for the salacious voyeuristic effect. Now I’m not one of these people who are against entertainment for entertainment’s sake, but give me a break! At least change the formula people. This is the “Real World” formula as it has been for something like the past seven seasons:
--Seven or eight people who look like they may or may not have been rejects from the latest teenybopper video casting. (You know the type; attractive but in no way memorable) arrive at apartment that is decorated in a painstakingly outrageous fashion.
--immediately the drama ensues given the fact there can never be an equal number of guys and girls. If one of the roommates is gay, the fifth wheel thing doesn’t quite come off, although lately they’ve been upping the ante by occasionally having one gay roommate and one bisexual roommate. Important note here: the gay roommate is nearly always a man and the bisexual roommate is usually female. Rarely do they have a bona fide lesbian on the show. My humble opinion? Bisexual women preserve the male fantasy of girl-on-girl action without any militant overtones.
--There are the obligatory hookups: “I think of all the people here I’ll connect with so-and-so because he/she is so hot/funny/cool/real,” the inevitable disillusionments: “He/she isn’t the person I thought he/she was. Too clingy/petty/etc. and I ain’t feelin’ that.”
-and of course what “Real World” season would be complete without the one roommate nobody can stand? We have Puck to thank for that.
I’m not going to go into all the reasons why the title “The Real World” is a misnomer. If the show was in any way like the real world, who would watch it? But must it be so formulaic? Take this latest crop of Las Vegas roomies. I think with this season MTV is throwing away any claim of legitimacy. In the first place there’s a huge statement being made by having the location be Las Vegas. What better place to really bring out those party instincts? Location is everything, and the pilot season already has one of the females starting out in bed with one guy and ending up in bed with another. I think that’s a “Real World” record. My prediction is Vegas is the star of this season, especially when one examines the roommates. These people not only look like everyone that you or I have ever met, they even resemble each other!
It is one thing to watch a formerly great show lose relevancy and entertainment value, and quite another to watch a mediocre show see how low it can go One could feel sorry for MTV. By being the reality TV trailblazers they have become victims of its hype. The desperation they portray in their constant catering to the lowest common denominator of viewers is pretty indicative that their time has past. As dynamic as the concept of music television was in the early eighties, it created a larger system of image and sexuality on TV, and MTV in trying to defy the stringent radio system has become trapped in a larger system of image-conscious programming that they themselves helped to create.
The show is still compelling in a gaping-at-car-wrecks kind of way. But if you really want edgy television, catch “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” over at UPN. Here’s a show that takes risks. By being so completely out of the realm of reality it enters this safe zone that enables them to confront real world issues on sexuality, the nature of youth, prejudice, and relationships. Ironic that a show on vampires can do so easily what a show based in “the real world” cannot.
No comments:
Post a Comment